children with food allergies and the legal implications for nurseries

Every nursery operator is acutely aware of the risk to children in their care who suffer from allergic reactions. Life-threatening reactions can be triggered by a variety of foods, including cheese, eggs, peanuts, kiwi fruits and strawberries, as well as bee stings. As well as the devastating personal effect, such an incident can lead to criminal prosecution (resulting in fines and/or imprisonment), a civil compensation claim, employment issues and the inevitable damage to reputation and decline in business.

The duty on nursery operators to look after the children in their care is enshrined in the Health and Safety at Work etc Act 1974, which provides that any employer has a duty to ensure, so far as is reasonably practicable, the safety of anyone who might be affected by the way in which it carries out its business.

The operator should therefore have robust written policies and procedures that reflect the risks identified by the process of risk assessments and set out what needs to be done to eliminate those risks or reduce them to the lowest level possible.

In dealing with controlling the risks identified with allergies, the key phrase in the Act to be borne in mind is 'so far as is reasonably practicable'. This is what a court will look at when assessing whether enough was done to prevent an incident.

The easiest way to prevent an allergy incident is of course to refuse admission to a child with an allergy. This is not necessarily desirable, but may be the only prudent course of action if a nursery does not have the appropriate skill set or resources. If a nursery does accept a child with an allergy, it will need to think carefully about the controls to be put in place, both on a general level and specifically in relation to that child and ensure that they are doing everything that is 'reasonably practicable'.

In the case of food allergies, controls to be put in place are likely to include:

  • obtaining full dietary information on admission, recording this in an easily accessible format and reviewing and updating it at regular intervals
  • making all nursery staff aware of any dietary issues and regularly reminding them eg by using labels and warning notices in the kitchen and serving areas etc
  • making all nursery staff aware of the signs and symptoms of allergic reactions and how to deal with them (including providing emergency contact numbers and an organisational flow chart of who will do what in an emergency to be kept in a specific folder for that child)
  • communicating regularly with the parents of a child with a known allergy
  • requesting other parents not to allow their child to bring certain foods into the nursery. This might be extended to informing other parents of the specific nature of allergies suffered by other children in the nursery, whilst ensuring confidentiality
  • taking steps to ensure food preparation areas are kept separate
  • taking steps to ensure that any change in food supplier is known and assurances about their products obtained and/or asking parents to provide food or a list of suitable branded food
  • staff training, including an annual update. Training could include a simulated allergy reaction. Attendance at any training should be recorded
  • ensuring (where appropriate) that handwashing facilities are equipped with disposable hand towels to minimise cross contamination of allergens

Controls are, however, useless unless they are implemented. Checking that controls are being followed can be done by way of monitoring, which should be recorded in writing. If there are any incidents or 'near misses', the controls (and the policy documents recording these) need to be amended to reflect lessons learnt and any amendments passed on to the nursery staff.

Operators must impress upon all of their staff the importance of knowing about the allergies of any children in the setting, and of complying with all of the setting's processes and procedures.

For more information, contact Mary Chant, partner and head of Blake Lapthorn solicitors' Health and Care group in Southampton on mary.chant@bllaw.co.uk or call 023 8085 7043.